Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Discussion of the power of words is interesting

There has been a lot of discussion over the rhetoric that has been used over the past several years to tear our country apart. People on both sides pretending that their words were not meant to inspire action. Give me a break. The whole purpose of rhetoric is to inspire action. The problem is that rhetoric can inspire but often times it cannot control. The shooting of Congressional Representative Giffords is horrible and there is no one cause but I think we can all agree the shooter did not just wake up in a social vacuum one morning and decide to kill. He is responsible for his thoughts, his actions and his schema but there were a great many people whose unquestioning self righteousness helped him form those ideas. Those who have rhetorical power should understand this power and take some responsibility for the way their audience understands the words, symbols and frameworks those words help people construct.

This coming week we are honoring a Community Builder whose rhetoric helped to change the direction of our nation. He had the power of rhetoric and he used the power of rhetoric. But, the reason I am using Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. as an example is that the rhetoric of Dr. King stood in direct contrast to the rhetoric of several other major civil rights activists and civil rights opponents. One of the major phrases in the speeches of many who were fighting for civil rights were words to the effect of "by any means possible." The reason white men as well as black men will honor Dr. King this Monday is that he cautioned against such "Means" and allowed people to see another way. His non-violent perspective did not make him popular in many civil rights groups. Contrast Dr. King's "Dream" with what we hear today and you can see and feel how rhetoric can build instead of destroy. On Monday, when we honor Dr. King, there may be more to our celebration that we might at first understand.

3 comments:

  1. I was encouraged as I watched President Obama's speech last night. He spoke words of hope and reconciliation. It is sometimes easier to get angry than to hope for something better and have to worry about being disappointed. But it is in the most difficult times, that hope is most important. Your blog post made me think we should all be dreaming big and using our words to inspire.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dick, yours is a good perspective that everyone could benefit from taking on, especially as we deal with change and controversial issues. I agree with your comments that while no one other than that individual can ultimately be held responsible for a person's actions, we most certainly can be held accountable for the influences that we make, intended or unintended.

    Our words matter. When we all take ownership of this truth we will all use our words more graciously towards each other. We can disagree, and in many instances, this is the most healthy of human interactions. However, when disagreement about ideas, values, concepts and principles turn into the devaluation of another human being, this is where the loss of self control begins. When we marginalize another person, we are reducing all people, including ourselves.

    Thanks so much for your words and your service. We miss you all very much.

    Tom Carpenter

    ReplyDelete